PhD Final Defense -- Tessa Clarizio

- Sponsor
- Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering
- Originating Calendar
- CEE Seminars and Conferences
Advancing Understanding of Aerosol Impacts over North America through Atmospheric
Chemistry Modeling and Satellite Remote Sensing
Advisor: Assistant Professor Hannah Horowitz
Abstract
Ambient fine particulate matter (diameter <2.5 microns, PM2.5) poses a major risk to human health,
with chemical composition playing an important role in determining toxicity. Ground-based
monitoring networks are spatially sparse, and measurements of PM2.5 chemical components are
even more limited. Atmospheric chemical transport modeling provides broad-scale estimates of
PM2.5 mass and composition but remains sensitive to uncertainties in emission inventories and
chemical formation mechanisms. Satellite aerosol optical depth (AOD) observations are widely
used to estimate surface PM2.5 and to constrain model simulations, but most applications rely on
Standard products with 8 to 40 hour latencies. Near-real-time (NRT) satellite AOD observations
(1 to 3 hour latency) offer the potential to improve the timeliness of satellite-constrained PM2.5
estimates. In addition to health impacts, PM2.5 influences the climate through its radiative impacts,
with implications for urban heat. This dissertation examines uncertainties in modeling PM2.5,
evaluates the application of NRT satellite AOD to constrain modeled PM2.5, and investigates
interdecadal trends and relationships between patterns of air pollution and urban heat in North
America.
First, the GEOS-Chem atmospheric model is used to evaluate how uncertainties in biomass
burning (BB) emissions, anthropogenic emissions, and secondary organic aerosol (SOA)
production mechanisms affect PM2.5 predictions over the contiguous U.S. during wildfire and nonwildfire
periods in 2021. Simulations driven by two estimates of wildfire emissions, two estimates
of anthropogenic emission, and two representations of organic aerosol formation are compared. In
August, simulations driven by the Global Fire Emissions Database (GFED) biomass burning
inventory produce PM2.5 concentrations >38% higher than that driven by the Global Fire
Assimilation System (GFAS), overestimating PM2.5 by more than 80%. Compared to groundbased
observations, the GFAS-driven simulation has the highest spatial correlation and lowest bias
in August. In December, performance is similar across scenarios, with the simple SOA scheme
yielding lower bias than the complex scheme. These findings demonstrate that BB inventories
dominate uncertainty in simulated PM2.5 during wildfire-impacted periods, whereas SOA
chemistry exerts greater influence when wildfire activity is limited. Accounting for these
uncertainties can guide the choice of model parameters and inform future model developments to
improve their policy or source attribution applications.
Second, modeled PM2.5 concentrations and chemical composition over the contiguous U.S. from
July 2021 to June 2022 is adjusted using satellite-derived AOD from both Standard and NRT
products. NRT-adjusted PM2.5 is broadly consistent with Standard-adjusted results. Satellite AOD
adjustment generally improves the modeled spatial variability but increases the bias against
observed PM2.5 concentrations, particularly during summer over the western U.S. Summertime
wildfire smoke introduces further uncertainty in AOD-PM2.5 scaling framework by altering the
relationship between AOD and surface PM2.5. Across all regions during summer, organic aerosol
is the most consistently overestimated PM2.5 component. Overall, the performance of satelliteadjusted
PM2.5 varies by species, region, and season, but does not depend on the latency of the
satellite AOD product.
Third, interdecadal changes (2002-2011 vs. 2012-2021) in urban-rural temperature differences
(ΔT), AOD, and surface PM2.5 concentrations are evaluated across cities in the U.S., Canada, and
Mexico. Air quality improved across much of the eastern U.S., while increasing wildfire activity
contributed to rising PM2.5 concentrations in parts of western U.S. and Canada. Relationships
between urban-rural differences in aerosol burden (ΔAOD and ΔPM2.5) and ΔT vary by region and
by diurnal period. Tropical regions show a positive relationship between ΔAOD and daytime ΔT,
whereas there is a negative relationship between ΔPM2.5 and nighttime ΔT. Arid regions
commonly exhibit a daytime urban cool island and nighttime urban heat island, with positive
associations between daytime ΔT and aerosol changes. Temperate regions display opposing
daytime and nighttime ΔPM2.5-ΔT relationships, whereas ΔAOD-ΔT only showed daytime
associations. No consistent relationship is observed in cold/continental climates between aerosols
and ΔT. The U.S. is the only country exhibiting a statistically significant positive nighttime
ΔAOD-ΔT relationship. These findings demonstrate that urban aerosol-temperature interactions
are regionally complex and do not translate uniformly across North America.
This dissertation advances understanding of key drivers of uncertainties in PM2.5 modeling,
evaluates the performance of NRT satellite-constrained PM2.5 estimates, and characterizes
evolving aerosol-urban heat interactions across North America. By integrating chemical transport
modeling, satellite remote sensing, and urban-scale analysis, this work provides insight into PM2.5
mass and composition across spatial and temporal scales. Continued integration of observational
and modeling approaches such as these is essential for reducing uncertainty in air pollution
estimates and informing effective mitigation strategies.